Throws and Blankets: The One Gift Nobody Returns

Throws are the safest gift in the home category because almost everyone uses one and almost nobody owns too many. The failure mode is buying a small decorative throw that covers a lap and nothing else.

We tested nine throws through a winter, judging them on warmth, pilling and whether they stayed in the living room.

How we chose

We scored on whether the throw was still on the sofa after a month, which is a better signal than any specification.

• At least 130 by 180 centimetres, so it covers an adult.
• Natural fibres or a high natural blend.
• Machine washable, or honest about being dry clean only.
• No pilling after two months of use.

What to buy

Lambswool for warmth

Warm, breathable and it looks better than synthetic fleece after a season. It will pill slightly, which is normal.

Cotton waffle for all-year use

Lighter, washes endlessly, and works in summer as well as winter. The best option for a household with pets.

Recycled wool blends for value

The under-fifty-dollar option that does not look cheap. Good for gifting to someone whose taste you are unsure about.

The bottom line

Buy a 130 by 180 centimetre lambswool throw in a neutral colour. If the household has pets or allergies, buy cotton waffle instead, which washes without drama.